Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Aggressive Trademark Policing Can Expand Your Protection and is Like Winning the "Super Bowl"

A while ago, a friend of a friend asked me for some advice regarding a cease and desist letter their organization received from the owner of the trademark "Iron Man" (World Triathlon Organization).  Their organization held team races which used the term "Iron Man" descriptively (i.e. to denote that the race would not include any substitutions, so that each person on the team had to "iron man" the race).  Not surprisingly, when I looked into this matter, it was easy to see that the trademark owner was using its superior resources (it is a big company) and stable of high-paid attorneys to shut down anyone from using the term whether it was in a trademark sense or not. The trademark owner went after every person/entity trying to use the term for their goods or services despite the goods and services having no relation to those promoted by WTO.  In one instance, WTO challenged the use of "Iron Man" in association with scientific measuring instruments causing the registrant to abandon its application.  Not sure how measuring instruments can be confused with triathlon-related activities, but clearly WTO does not want anyone to use "Iron Man."

My advice to this small organization was to just give up using the term because litigation would financially ruin the organization and there was no doubt that World Triathlon Organization ("WTO") had the resources to see the litigation out to its conclusion.  While legally, there was a strong argument that the small organization was not doing anything wrong, testing that theory would undoubtedly take years and hundreds of thousands of dollars in litigation costs.
 
Remember, trademarks are supposed to identify source and not confuse consumers, but not to take words or phrases out of the lexicon.  That is to say, a person should be able to use a term to describe a product even if the term is the trademark of another (e.g. I am wearing Nike shoes).  As long as the person or entity is not inferring that it is a sponsor or affiliate of the trademark owner, then from a strictly legal sense that should be okay.

Unfortunately, some companies, like the owner of "Iron Man" aggressively fire off cease and desist letters, oppose trademark registrations, or file lawsuits to those using their trademarked name legitimately.  The most recent example of this is the NFL's aggressiveness in not allowing those not authorized by the NFL to use the term "Super Bowl."  Look at the advertisements from companies not from "official sponsors" of the event, they will advertise deals for the "big game" or "super" savings, but will not use the term "Super Bowl."  That is because the NFL polices any such use and has the means to drive many of the smaller entities out of business with litigation, or make life miserable for the bigger companies who'd rather spend their money on promotions or building their business and not litigation.

As a trademark attorney, I advocate strongly for my clients to ensure that their rights are protected.  But, on the other side sometimes legality should give way to reality so that my clients can continue to grow their businesses.  

Monday, August 8, 2011

Personal Jurisdiction and Forum Selection Clauses


            Does your acceptance of a license agreement which contains a clause selecting a certain forum to litigate any disputes arising from the license mean that you have submitted to the jurisdiction chosen to be the forum? At least one California Appellate opinion answers that question in the negative.  In Global Packaging, Inc. v. Sup. Ct. (Epicor Software Corp.), the court said that a forum selection clause is not mean that a party consents to personal jurisdiction in that forum.  In Global Packaging, Global Packaging , a Pennsylvania corporation, licensed some software from Epicor Software, a Delaware corporation with a principal place of business in Orange County.  Epicor’s ELU (End License User Agreement) provided that the venue of any litigation involving the license agreement shall be in Orange County, California or in the jurisdiction in which the software is located.  As luck would have it, a dispute arose between the parties over payment and Epicor initiated litigation in Orange County.  Global Packaging challenged the court’s personal jurisdiction over it.  The trial court determined that the forum-selection clause was the same as a consent to jurisdiction.  The appellate court disagreed.
            The appellate took great pains, of which I will not bore you here, to distinguish between jurisdiction and venue (or forum).  As stated by the court, in general terms there are four ways in which a court may obtain jurisdiction over a person (or entity):  1)  the person’s residence or presence in the forum state; 2) the person’s activities are conducted in the forum state such that exercising jurisdiction comports with “traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice;” 3) the person participates in a lawsuit in the forum; or 4) the person consents to jurisdiction in the forum. 
            The question before the Global Packaging court was whether an agreement to bring an action in a particular forum is the same as consenting to jurisdiction in that forum.  The answer is no because the two concepts separate.  Essentially, the court stated that to select a forum, a party must somehow be subject to personal jurisdiction of the forum (see the four ways to obtain jurisdiction above).  In Global Packaging, the court could not assert personal jurisdiction over Global Packaging by any of the listed means. 
            What does this mean for you who may be relying on forum selection clauses to assert jurisdiction over a wayward licensee? It means that you should update your license agreements to include an explicit consent to personal jurisdiction in the forum which you wish to select.  In an abundance of caution, I would recommend having the party initial by the consent to jurisdiction in the forum.  If you are the party being hailed into a far away court, determine if there is any way for the court to assert personal jurisdiction over you, including reviewing the contracts you signed and determine if there is a provision wherein you consent to personal jurisdiction in the far away court.